As the curtain falls on the Paramount Network neo-Western “Yellowstone,” anticipation and speculation about its final episodes in November have reached a fever pitch. One central question looms large: will Kevin Costner make a triumphant return as John Dutton, or have viewers bid farewell to the iconic character for good?
The Dutton Dilemma: How Will He Exit?
The impending conclusion has sparked numerous theories, but none more intriguing than the possibility of revisiting John Dutton’s past health crisis. A theory gaining traction suggests a resurrection of the colon cancer storyline from season one, a storyline that was swiftly wrapped up in season two with the revelation of a ruptured ulcer, not cancer.
The Controversial Theory
ScreenRant has reported on this controversial theory, indicating a resurgence of interest in John Dutton’s supposed battle with colon cancer. While it was a significant plot point in the first season, the idea of revisiting this narrative element now seems, to many, incredibly misguided.
Backlash from Fans
Fans, understandably, express concern and discontent at the prospect of such a lackluster resolution for John Dutton. Bringing back a resolved health crisis feels not only anticlimactic but risks alienating a dedicated fan base that has eagerly awaited a grand and dramatic finale.
A Plea for a Grand Exit
“Yellowstone” has built its reputation on delivering an intense and violent narrative, with the imminent collapse of the ranch acting as the fulcrum. The notion of resolving the chaos by disposing of John Dutton through a recycled cancer plotline feels not just uninspired but potentially detrimental to the show’s legacy.
Rejecting the Mundane
The first half of season five left fans with Jamie committing to dismantling his own family, setting the stage for an explosive second half. Proposing a subdued exit via cancer revival threatens to undermine the high-stakes tension the series has carefully cultivated.
Better Alternatives: Crafting a Riveting Conclusion
Even if Costner never graces the screen again, alternative pathways exist to bid farewell to the iconic character without resorting to a predictable health crisis.
Unleashing the Chaos
A staged attack, assassination, or a dramatic event akin to a bombing could provide a more fitting end. The possibilities are vast, but one thing remains clear – revisiting a resolved health issue is a disservice to fans eagerly awaiting an epic conclusion.
The Horizon Beyond “Yellowstone”
Amidst rumors of Kevin Costner’s departure due to creative differences and conflicting schedules, fans are left pondering the fate of John Dutton. The emergence of a new movie series directed and starring Costner, titled “Horizon: An American Saga,” adds to the uncertainty.
Conflicting Reports
Reports on Costner’s involvement in season five, part two, vary, leaving fans speculating about John Dutton III’s exit strategy. While official statements remain elusive, the fan community is already theorizing potential storylines.
Fan Theories: Unearthing Season One’s Forgotten Plot
A compelling fan theory suggests that the answers to John Dutton’s exit lie in the depths of the show’s inaugural season. Creative differences and scheduling conflicts aside, fans delve into the possibility of reviving an abandoned plot from season one for a fitting end to John Dutton’s journey.
The Unresolved Colon Cancer Plot
Season one introduced tensions as John faced a battle with colon cancer, a crisis that was seemingly averted with successful surgery. However, a Reddit user proposes revisiting this health challenge, taking it to its final stages, providing a poignant and memorable conclusion.
The Envisioned Farewell
If Taylor Sheridan were to embrace this unexpected twist, the final episodes could explore the last stages of John Dutton’s life. A final battle for the ranch, followed by a poignant scene with his loyal confidant Rip Wheeler, could offer a satisfying yet heart-wrenching farewell.
A Unique Proposition
In this envisioned ending, John Dutton, battered and bruised but alive, requests Rip to end his life in a secluded moment. This unique twist ensures an emotional resolution while sparing the family from the harsh truth.
Conclusion: An Uncertain Future
As “Yellowstone” fans eagerly await the unfolding of season five’s final chapters, the speculations and theories surrounding John Dutton’s exit continue to captivate. Whether the show embraces an unexpected twist or falls into the predictable realms of a resolved health crisis, only time will reveal the fate of the iconic Dutton patriarch.
Read: Exploring Pirates of the Caribbean 6: Rumors, Fan Hopes, and the Elusive Captain Jack Sparrow
1 thought on “A Deep Dive into “Yellowstone” Ending Theories: Unveiling the Fate of John Dutton”